Le test de performance des pneus d'hiver 2022 Auto Zeitung a testé huit pneus d'hiver populaires en 225/45 R17.
Continental, Bridgestone et Michelin ont tous bien performé, le Continental WinterContact TS870 remportant une nouvelle victoire lors des tests de pneus hiver 2022 grâce à des performances bien équilibrées dans toutes les conditions, le Bridgestone Blizzak LM005 se comporte extrêmement bien sur sol sec et mouillé, et le Michelin Alpin 6 offrant une bonne adhérence dans toutes les conditions.
Sec
Le Nokian SnowProof P était le meilleur en freinage à sec, arrêtant l'Audi A3 quatre mètres plus court que le pire du groupe.
Le Bridgestone Blizzak LM005 était le meilleur pneu lors de la conduite sur sol sec, battant de peu le Continental WinterContact TS870.
Le Continental et le Bridgestone étaient aussi les meilleurs subjectivement sur le sec.
Humide
Le freinage sur sol mouillé a de nouveau été mené par l'impressionnante paire Bridgestone et Continental.
Tout comme la tenue de route sur sol mouillé, mais cette fois avec Continental devant Bridgestone. Michelin s'est à nouveau placé à une respectable troisième place.
Conti, Bridgestone et Michelin étaient aussi subjectivement les favoris des testeurs.
Continental et Bridgestone avaient également la meilleure résistance à l'aquaplaning en ligne droite.
Neiger
Continental était à nouveau le meilleur en freinage sur neige, mais cette fois Giti a pris la deuxième place avec le GitiWinterW2 !
Michelin est en tête de la traction neige, suivi de près par la Fulda.
Continental et Michelin étaient de retour aux avant-postes lors du traitement de la neige.
Environnement
Le Nokian était le pneu le plus silencieux testé en externe.
Et offrait les meilleurs niveaux de confort subjectifs.
Le Nokian avait également la consommation de carburant la plus faible lors des tests, suivi de Bridgestone et Continental.
Le Giti était le pneu le moins cher du test et le Michelin le plus cher.
Résultats
|
- 225/45 R17 94V
- EU Label: C/B/70
- Weight: 9.3kgs
- Tread: 8.7mm
- 3PMSF: no
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 4th | 46.1 M | 45 M | +1.1 M | 97.61% | Manipulation à sec | 2nd | 63.3 s | 63.1 s | +0.2 s | 99.68% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 1st | 30 Points | | | 100% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 2nd | 51.9 M | 50.3 M | +1.6 M | 96.92% | Manipulation humide | 1st | 89.7 s | | | 100% | Subj. Manipulation humide | 1st | 45 Points | | | 100% | Aquaplaning droit | 1st | 75.2 Km/H | | | 100% | Aquaplaning courbe | 1st | 2.96 m/sec2 | | | 100% | Freinage sur neige | 1st | 26 M | | | 100% | Traction sur neige | 4th | 2712 N | 2782 N | -70 N | 97.48% | Gestion de la neige | 1st | 81.8 s | | | 100% | Subj. Manipulation de la neige | 1st | 30 Points | | | 100% | Subj. Confort | 2nd | 7 Points | 8 Points | -1 Points | 87.5% | Bruit | 2nd | 71 dB | 70 dB | +1 dB | 98.59% | Prix | 7th | 640 | 375 | +265 | 58.59% | Résistance au roulement | 3rd | 8.1 kg / t | 7.3 kg / t | +0.8 kg / t | 90.12% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
- 225/45 R17 94V
- EU Label: C/A/71
- Weight: 9.5kgs
- Tread: 8.3mm
- 3PMSF: no
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 2nd | 45.5 M | 45 M | +0.5 M | 98.9% | Manipulation à sec | 1st | 63.1 s | | | 100% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 2nd | 29 Points | 30 Points | -1 Points | 96.67% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 1st | 50.3 M | | | 100% | Manipulation humide | 2nd | 90.2 s | 89.7 s | +0.5 s | 99.45% | Subj. Manipulation humide | 2nd | 42 Points | 45 Points | -3 Points | 93.33% | Aquaplaning droit | 2nd | 74.4 Km/H | 75.2 Km/H | -0.8 Km/H | 98.94% | Aquaplaning courbe | 5th | 2.8 m/sec2 | 2.96 m/sec2 | -0.16 m/sec2 | 94.59% | Freinage sur neige | 4th | 27 M | 26 M | +1 M | 96.3% | Traction sur neige | 7th | 2683 N | 2782 N | -99 N | 96.44% | Gestion de la neige | 6th | 84.4 s | 81.8 s | +2.6 s | 96.92% | Subj. Manipulation de la neige | 6th | 20 Points | 30 Points | -10 Points | 66.67% | Subj. Confort | 2nd | 7 Points | 8 Points | -1 Points | 87.5% | Bruit | 4th | 72 dB | 70 dB | +2 dB | 97.22% | Prix | 4th | 535 | 375 | +160 | 70.09% | Résistance au roulement | 2nd | 8 kg / t | 7.3 kg / t | +0.7 kg / t | 91.25% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
- 225/45 R17 94V
- EU Label: C/B/69
- Weight: 9.1kgs
- Tread: 8mm
- 3PMSF: no
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 6th | 46.4 M | 45 M | +1.4 M | 96.98% | Manipulation à sec | 7th | 64.5 s | 63.1 s | +1.4 s | 97.83% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 6th | 24 Points | 30 Points | -6 Points | 80% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 3rd | 53.3 M | 50.3 M | +3 M | 94.37% | Manipulation humide | 3rd | 91.2 s | 89.7 s | +1.5 s | 98.36% | Subj. Manipulation humide | 3rd | 37 Points | 45 Points | -8 Points | 82.22% | Aquaplaning droit | 4th | 73.4 Km/H | 75.2 Km/H | -1.8 Km/H | 97.61% | Aquaplaning courbe | 4th | 2.85 m/sec2 | 2.96 m/sec2 | -0.11 m/sec2 | 96.28% | Freinage sur neige | 7th | 27.3 M | 26 M | +1.3 M | 95.24% | Traction sur neige | 1st | 2782 N | | | 100% | Gestion de la neige | 2nd | 82.9 s | 81.8 s | +1.1 s | 98.67% | Subj. Manipulation de la neige | 4th | 22 Points | 30 Points | -8 Points | 73.33% | Subj. Confort | 2nd | 7 Points | 8 Points | -1 Points | 87.5% | Bruit | 4th | 72 dB | 70 dB | +2 dB | 97.22% | Prix | 8th | 660 | 375 | +285 | 56.82% | Résistance au roulement | 6th | 8.8 kg / t | 7.3 kg / t | +1.5 kg / t | 82.95% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
- 225/45 R17 94V
- EU Label: B/B/70
- Weight: 9.6kgs
- Tread: 8.5mm
- 3PMSF: no
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 1st | 45 M | | | 100% | Manipulation à sec | 3rd | 63.9 s | 63.1 s | +0.8 s | 98.75% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 3rd | 27 Points | 30 Points | -3 Points | 90% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 5th | 55.5 M | 50.3 M | +5.2 M | 90.63% | Manipulation humide | 7th | 95.5 s | 89.7 s | +5.8 s | 93.93% | Subj. Manipulation humide | 7th | 19 Points | 45 Points | -26 Points | 42.22% | Aquaplaning droit | 8th | 64.8 Km/H | 75.2 Km/H | -10.4 Km/H | 86.17% | Aquaplaning courbe | 8th | 1.61 m/sec2 | 2.96 m/sec2 | -1.35 m/sec2 | 54.39% | Freinage sur neige | 4th | 27 M | 26 M | +1 M | 96.3% | Traction sur neige | 5th | 2705 N | 2782 N | -77 N | 97.23% | Gestion de la neige | 4th | 83.2 s | 81.8 s | +1.4 s | 98.32% | Subj. Manipulation de la neige | 3rd | 23 Points | 30 Points | -7 Points | 76.67% | Subj. Confort | 1st | 8 Points | | | 100% | Bruit | 1st | 70 dB | | | 100% | Prix | 5th | 575 | 375 | +200 | 65.22% | Résistance au roulement | 1st | 7.3 kg / t | | | 100% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
- 225/45 R17 94V
- EU Label: D/B/72
- Weight: 9.7kgs
- Tread: 8.2mm
- 3PMSF: no
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 5th | 46.3 M | 45 M | +1.3 M | 97.19% | Manipulation à sec | 3rd | 63.9 s | 63.1 s | +0.8 s | 98.75% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 3rd | 27 Points | 30 Points | -3 Points | 90% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 4th | 53.6 M | 50.3 M | +3.3 M | 93.84% | Manipulation humide | 4th | 92.2 s | 89.7 s | +2.5 s | 97.29% | Subj. Manipulation humide | 5th | 26 Points | 45 Points | -19 Points | 57.78% | Aquaplaning droit | 7th | 71.4 Km/H | 75.2 Km/H | -3.8 Km/H | 94.95% | Aquaplaning courbe | 6th | 2.67 m/sec2 | 2.96 m/sec2 | -0.29 m/sec2 | 90.2% | Freinage sur neige | 4th | 27 M | 26 M | +1 M | 96.3% | Traction sur neige | 5th | 2705 N | 2782 N | -77 N | 97.23% | Gestion de la neige | 7th | 84.7 s | 81.8 s | +2.9 s | 96.58% | Subj. Manipulation de la neige | 7th | 17 Points | 30 Points | -13 Points | 56.67% | Subj. Confort | 2nd | 7 Points | 8 Points | -1 Points | 87.5% | Bruit | 7th | 73 dB | 70 dB | +3 dB | 95.89% | Prix | 3rd | 515 | 375 | +140 | 72.82% | Résistance au roulement | 7th | 9.1 kg / t | 7.3 kg / t | +1.8 kg / t | 80.22% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
- 225/45 R17 94V
- EU Label: C/C/72
- Weight: 9.1kgs
- Tread: 9mm
- 3PMSF: no
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 7th | 48.1 M | 45 M | +3.1 M | 93.56% | Manipulation à sec | 7th | 64.5 s | 63.1 s | +1.4 s | 97.83% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 8th | 22 Points | 30 Points | -8 Points | 73.33% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 7th | 59.2 M | 50.3 M | +8.9 M | 84.97% | Manipulation humide | 6th | 95 s | 89.7 s | +5.3 s | 94.42% | Subj. Manipulation humide | 6th | 21 Points | 45 Points | -24 Points | 46.67% | Aquaplaning droit | 5th | 72.7 Km/H | 75.2 Km/H | -2.5 Km/H | 96.68% | Aquaplaning courbe | 2nd | 2.92 m/sec2 | 2.96 m/sec2 | -0.04 m/sec2 | 98.65% | Freinage sur neige | 2nd | 26.7 M | 26 M | +0.7 M | 97.38% | Traction sur neige | 2nd | 2750 N | 2782 N | -32 N | 98.85% | Gestion de la neige | 2nd | 82.9 s | 81.8 s | +1.1 s | 98.67% | Subj. Manipulation de la neige | 2nd | 27 Points | 30 Points | -3 Points | 90% | Subj. Confort | 8th | 6 Points | 8 Points | -2 Points | 75% | Bruit | 7th | 73 dB | 70 dB | +3 dB | 95.89% | Prix | 2nd | 475 | 375 | +100 | 78.95% | Résistance au roulement | 4th | 8.5 kg / t | 7.3 kg / t | +1.2 kg / t | 85.88% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
- 225/45 R17 94V
- EU Label: C/B/72
- Weight: 9.3kgs
- Tread: 8.9mm
- 3PMSF: no
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 3rd | 45.8 M | 45 M | +0.8 M | 98.25% | Manipulation à sec | 6th | 64.3 s | 63.1 s | +1.2 s | 98.13% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 7th | 23 Points | 30 Points | -7 Points | 76.67% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 6th | 55.8 M | 50.3 M | +5.5 M | 90.14% | Manipulation humide | 5th | 92.5 s | 89.7 s | +2.8 s | 96.97% | Subj. Manipulation humide | 4th | 29 Points | 45 Points | -16 Points | 64.44% | Aquaplaning droit | 6th | 72.6 Km/H | 75.2 Km/H | -2.6 Km/H | 96.54% | Aquaplaning courbe | 7th | 2.64 m/sec2 | 2.96 m/sec2 | -0.32 m/sec2 | 89.19% | Freinage sur neige | 8th | 28.1 M | 26 M | +2.1 M | 92.53% | Traction sur neige | 8th | 2661 N | 2782 N | -121 N | 95.65% | Gestion de la neige | 8th | 85.2 s | 81.8 s | +3.4 s | 96.01% | Subj. Manipulation de la neige | 8th | 14 Points | 30 Points | -16 Points | 46.67% | Subj. Confort | 2nd | 7 Points | 8 Points | -1 Points | 87.5% | Bruit | 4th | 72 dB | 70 dB | +2 dB | 97.22% | Prix | 6th | 600 | 375 | +225 | 62.5% | Résistance au roulement | 5th | 8.6 kg / t | 7.3 kg / t | +1.3 kg / t | 84.88% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
- 225/45 R17 94V
- EU Label: D/B/71
- Weight: 9.8kgs
- Tread: 8.9mm
- 3PMSF: no
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 8th | 49 M | 45 M | +4 M | 91.84% | Manipulation à sec | 5th | 64.1 s | 63.1 s | +1 s | 98.44% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 5th | 26 Points | 30 Points | -4 Points | 86.67% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 8th | 61.4 M | 50.3 M | +11.1 M | 81.92% | Manipulation humide | 8th | 96.3 s | 89.7 s | +6.6 s | 93.15% | Subj. Manipulation humide | 8th | 17 Points | 45 Points | -28 Points | 37.78% | Aquaplaning droit | 3rd | 73.9 Km/H | 75.2 Km/H | -1.3 Km/H | 98.27% | Aquaplaning courbe | 2nd | 2.92 m/sec2 | 2.96 m/sec2 | -0.04 m/sec2 | 98.65% | Freinage sur neige | 2nd | 26.7 M | 26 M | +0.7 M | 97.38% | Traction sur neige | 3rd | 2735 N | 2782 N | -47 N | 98.31% | Gestion de la neige | 5th | 83.9 s | 81.8 s | +2.1 s | 97.5% | Subj. Manipulation de la neige | 5th | 21 Points | 30 Points | -9 Points | 70% | Subj. Confort | 2nd | 7 Points | 8 Points | -1 Points | 87.5% | Bruit | 2nd | 71 dB | 70 dB | +1 dB | 98.59% | Prix | 1st | 375 | | | 100% | Résistance au roulement | 8th | 9.3 kg / t | 7.3 kg / t | +2 kg / t | 78.49% | Lire les rapports d'essais |