Les spécialistes des hivers extrêmes de Vi Bilagare sont de retour pour tester les derniers et meilleurs pneus hiver à friction sans clous. Cette année, ils ont non seulement testé sept des composés nordiques à friction sans crampons les plus populaires dans la taille de pneu populaire 225/45 R17, mais ils ont également inclus un pneu plus ancien pour voir les effets du vieillissement. Le pneu le plus ancien est un Nokian Hakkapeliitta R2 de 8 ans, peu utilisé (6 mm restants), qui a du pain sur la planche, car son frère "deux générations plus récent", le Hakkapeliitta R5, est également inclus dans ce test !
En raison de contraintes de temps, nous nous contenterons de présenter les données, en nous rendant sur le site Web de Vi Vilagare pour consulter l'article complet.
Glace
Freinage sur glace
Traction sur glace
Manipulation de la glace
Neige
Freinage sur neige
Traction sur neige
Manipulation de la neige
Mouillé
Freinage sur sol mouillé
Manipulation humide
Aqua droit
Sec
Freinage à sec
Sousj. Manipulation à sec
Confort
Bruit
Valeur
Consommation de carburant
Résultats
|
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 3rd | 30.32 M | 29.23 M | +1.09 M | 96.41% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 3rd | 4 Points | 5 Points | -1 Points | 80% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 3rd | 39.31 M | 37.55 M | +1.76 M | 95.52% | Manipulation humide | 2nd | 41.4 s | 41 s | +0.4 s | 99.03% | Aquaplaning droit | 3rd | 62.7 Km/H | 66 Km/H | -3.3 Km/H | 95% | Freinage sur neige | 4th | 12.34 M | 12.19 M | +0.15 M | 98.78% | Traction sur neige | 3rd | 4.55 s | 4.44 s | +0.11 s | 97.58% | Gestion de la neige | 2nd | 75.7 s | 75.5 s | +0.2 s | 99.74% | Freinage sur glace | 2nd | 12.32 M | 12.09 M | +0.23 M | 98.13% | Traction sur glace | 3rd | 7.82 s | 7.32 s | +0.5 s | 93.61% | Manipulation des glaces | 1st | 44.5 s | | | 100% | Bruit | 3rd | 74 dB | 73.7 dB | +0.3 dB | 99.59% | Consommation de carburant | 4th | 5 l/100km | 4.8 l/100km | +0.2 l/100km | 96% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 6th | 30.9 M | 29.23 M | +1.67 M | 94.6% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 1st | 5 Points | | | 100% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 1st | 37.55 M | | | 100% | Manipulation humide | 1st | 41 s | | | 100% | Aquaplaning droit | 1st | 66 Km/H | | | 100% | Freinage sur neige | 1st | 12.19 M | | | 100% | Traction sur neige | 1st | 4.44 s | | | 100% | Gestion de la neige | 3rd | 75.9 s | 75.5 s | +0.4 s | 99.47% | Freinage sur glace | 4th | 13 M | 12.09 M | +0.91 M | 93% | Traction sur glace | 5th | 8.43 s | 7.32 s | +1.11 s | 86.83% | Manipulation des glaces | 5th | 46.7 s | 44.5 s | +2.2 s | 95.29% | Bruit | 3rd | 74 dB | 73.7 dB | +0.3 dB | 99.59% | Consommation de carburant | 2nd | 4.85 l/100km | 4.8 l/100km | +0.05 l/100km | 98.97% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 5th | 30.65 M | 29.23 M | +1.42 M | 95.37% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 5th | 3 Points | 5 Points | -2 Points | 60% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 4th | 40.28 M | 37.55 M | +2.73 M | 93.22% | Manipulation humide | 3rd | 42 s | 41 s | +1 s | 97.62% | Aquaplaning droit | 4th | 61.4 Km/H | 66 Km/H | -4.6 Km/H | 93.03% | Freinage sur neige | 5th | 12.52 M | 12.19 M | +0.33 M | 97.36% | Traction sur neige | 4th | 4.57 s | 4.44 s | +0.13 s | 97.16% | Gestion de la neige | 1st | 75.5 s | | | 100% | Freinage sur glace | 3rd | 12.49 M | 12.09 M | +0.4 M | 96.8% | Traction sur glace | 2nd | 7.52 s | 7.32 s | +0.2 s | 97.34% | Manipulation des glaces | 2nd | 44.7 s | 44.5 s | +0.2 s | 99.55% | Bruit | 5th | 74.3 dB | 73.7 dB | +0.6 dB | 99.19% | Consommation de carburant | 3rd | 4.9 l/100km | 4.8 l/100km | +0.1 l/100km | 97.96% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 7th | 30.96 M | 29.23 M | +1.73 M | 94.41% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 3rd | 4 Points | 5 Points | -1 Points | 80% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 2nd | 38.4 M | 37.55 M | +0.85 M | 97.79% | Manipulation humide | 4th | 42.1 s | 41 s | +1.1 s | 97.39% | Aquaplaning droit | 2nd | 65 Km/H | 66 Km/H | -1 Km/H | 98.48% | Freinage sur neige | 2nd | 12.21 M | 12.19 M | +0.02 M | 99.84% | Traction sur neige | 4th | 4.57 s | 4.44 s | +0.13 s | 97.16% | Gestion de la neige | 6th | 76.7 s | 75.5 s | +1.2 s | 98.44% | Freinage sur glace | 1st | 12.09 M | | | 100% | Traction sur glace | 1st | 7.32 s | | | 100% | Manipulation des glaces | 6th | 47.1 s | 44.5 s | +2.6 s | 94.48% | Bruit | 7th | 74.5 dB | 73.7 dB | +0.8 dB | 98.93% | Consommation de carburant | 7th | 5.15 l/100km | 4.8 l/100km | +0.35 l/100km | 93.2% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 2nd | 30.03 M | 29.23 M | +0.8 M | 97.34% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 7th | 2 Points | 5 Points | -3 Points | 40% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 5th | 40.74 M | 37.55 M | +3.19 M | 92.17% | Manipulation humide | 8th | 43.9 s | 41 s | +2.9 s | 93.39% | Aquaplaning droit | 7th | 59.8 Km/H | 66 Km/H | -6.2 Km/H | 90.61% | Freinage sur neige | 8th | 12.77 M | 12.19 M | +0.58 M | 95.46% | Traction sur neige | 6th | 4.59 s | 4.44 s | +0.15 s | 96.73% | Gestion de la neige | 5th | 76.6 s | 75.5 s | +1.1 s | 98.56% | Freinage sur glace | 6th | 13.3 M | 12.09 M | +1.21 M | 90.9% | Traction sur glace | 4th | 8.05 s | 7.32 s | +0.73 s | 90.93% | Manipulation des glaces | 3rd | 44.9 s | 44.5 s | +0.4 s | 99.11% | Bruit | 1st | 73.7 dB | | | 100% | Consommation de carburant | 8th | 5.2 l/100km | 4.8 l/100km | +0.4 l/100km | 92.31% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 8th | 31.46 M | 29.23 M | +2.23 M | 92.91% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 1st | 5 Points | | | 100% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 8th | 43.34 M | 37.55 M | +5.79 M | 86.64% | Manipulation humide | 6th | 42.8 s | 41 s | +1.8 s | 95.79% | Aquaplaning droit | 6th | 60.5 Km/H | 66 Km/H | -5.5 Km/H | 91.67% | Freinage sur neige | 3rd | 12.27 M | 12.19 M | +0.08 M | 99.35% | Traction sur neige | 2nd | 4.49 s | 4.44 s | +0.05 s | 98.89% | Gestion de la neige | 4th | 76.4 s | 75.5 s | +0.9 s | 98.82% | Freinage sur glace | 5th | 13.23 M | 12.09 M | +1.14 M | 91.38% | Traction sur glace | 6th | 8.97 s | 7.32 s | +1.65 s | 81.61% | Manipulation des glaces | 4th | 46 s | 44.5 s | +1.5 s | 96.74% | Bruit | 2nd | 73.9 dB | 73.7 dB | +0.2 dB | 99.73% | Consommation de carburant | 5th | 5.05 l/100km | 4.8 l/100km | +0.25 l/100km | 95.05% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 4th | 30.37 M | 29.23 M | +1.14 M | 96.25% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 5th | 3 Points | 5 Points | -2 Points | 60% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 7th | 42.19 M | 37.55 M | +4.64 M | 89% | Manipulation humide | 5th | 42.4 s | 41 s | +1.4 s | 96.7% | Aquaplaning droit | 5th | 61 Km/H | 66 Km/H | -5 Km/H | 92.42% | Freinage sur neige | 5th | 12.52 M | 12.19 M | +0.33 M | 97.36% | Traction sur neige | 8th | 4.68 s | 4.44 s | +0.24 s | 94.87% | Gestion de la neige | 7th | 79.9 s | 75.5 s | +4.4 s | 94.49% | Freinage sur glace | 7th | 13.93 M | 12.09 M | +1.84 M | 86.79% | Traction sur glace | 7th | 9.17 s | 7.32 s | +1.85 s | 79.83% | Manipulation des glaces | 7th | 48.6 s | 44.5 s | +4.1 s | 91.56% | Bruit | 5th | 74.3 dB | 73.7 dB | +0.6 dB | 99.19% | Consommation de carburant | 6th | 5.1 l/100km | 4.8 l/100km | +0.3 l/100km | 94.12% | Lire les rapports d'essais |
|
|
Test | # | Result | Best | Difference | % |
Freinage à sec | 1st | 29.23 M | | | 100% | Subj. Manipulation à sec | 7th | 2 Points | 5 Points | -3 Points | 40% | Freinage sur sol mouillé | 6th | 40.88 M | 37.55 M | +3.33 M | 91.85% | Manipulation humide | 7th | 43.7 s | 41 s | +2.7 s | 93.82% | Aquaplaning droit | 8th | 56.6 Km/H | 66 Km/H | -9.4 Km/H | 85.76% | Freinage sur neige | 7th | 12.73 M | 12.19 M | +0.54 M | 95.76% | Traction sur neige | 7th | 4.6 s | 4.44 s | +0.16 s | 96.52% | Gestion de la neige | 8th | 80.7 s | 75.5 s | +5.2 s | 93.56% | Freinage sur glace | 8th | 14.04 M | 12.09 M | +1.95 M | 86.11% | Traction sur glace | 8th | 10.7 s | 7.32 s | +3.38 s | 68.41% | Manipulation des glaces | 8th | 49 s | 44.5 s | +4.5 s | 90.82% | Bruit | 8th | 75.5 dB | 73.7 dB | +1.8 dB | 97.62% | Consommation de carburant | 1st | 4.8 l/100km | | | 100% | Lire les rapports d'essais |